“Judge not . . .” is a well-known passage . . . even by not-yet-Christians. How many times have we heard not-yet-Christians, with an index finger wagging in the air and an “aha”, remind us? Though Matthew 7:1-5 is well-known, verse 6 is much less known:
“Do not give dogs what is holy, and do not throw your pearls before pigs, lest they trample them underfoot and turn to attack you.(Matthew 7:6 ESV)
The fact is, verses 1-6 form the complete idea. What happens when you take them together? Let’s put the two together in abbreviated form:
Wait now; if we’ve just determined that somebody is a dog or a pig, did we not just judge? And Jesus, of all people, compels us to withhold from these people. Does this seem contradictory?
[I can put silly stuff on my blog since only 5 people read it]
Let’s examine the “Judge not” idea first. If we look at this parallel saying in Luke 6:36-38, we can see that this “judge not” saying happens in the context of granting mercy. Without going into a long explanation here (go to my “Measuring by Mercy” post for more on this), I’ll suggest that this means something like “ don’t judge them unworthy of the same mercy that you rely upon.” So, on the one hand, we look at a person, no matter how harried the situation, and know that he needs mercy upon mercy . . . like me.
Now let’s take a look at the “dogs and pigs” idea. I think it’s as simple as this: “don’t grant scoundrels who defame The Gospel the courtesy of hearing truth that they then only defame. . . i.e., keep your mouth shut.”
I just wrote “as simple as . . . .” Is it ever simple to know what to say, how to say it, or if to say it? Not so much. This is the reason it’s not simple: Theses two saying represent two sides of an issue, two extremes, one juxtaposition. I view it like this:
Someplace in between the two extremes is the right way to respond to people and circumstances. This situation calls for mercy upon mercy. That situation calls for you to say nothing. Those situations call for a rebuke. Others call for a silent hug. Who knows? God knows. How do you know? ASK, SEEK, KNOCK. The Holy Spirit will tell you where the Narrow Way is right now, with this person, under these influences, and in this circumstance. Don’t try to figure it out yourself. The way is too narrow, variable, and circumstantial for you to find it without asking.
Loving does not look like the same thing in every case, not even with the same person the next time. It will turn out closer to one side of the juxtaposition or the other.









